Navigating cryptocurrency investments can feel overwhelming, especially for newcomers, with what seem like countless options and speculative forums touting the next "hidden gem." While some stick to Bitcoin (BTC), others dive into altcoins, drawn by the promise of higher returns but facing less transparency, greater volatility, and added risks.

For those looking for a simpler path, crypto index funds offer a more accessible way to engage with decentralized finance (DeFi) while avoiding the complexities of managing various individual assets.

In this guide, we’ll explore crypto index funds, their types, pros and cons, how to invest in them, and their role in transforming cryptocurrency investing.

What is a crypto index fund?

Think of a crypto index fund as a basket of hand-picked cryptocurrencies – a curated collection of digital assets selected based on factors like market value or specific focus areas like digital art, Web3 gaming, or real-world assets (RWAs). Rather than buying the individual coins in the basket, you invest in the basket. This allows you to gain exposure to the aggregate performance of its assets without needing to manage each cryptocurrency separately.

Typically, a third party manages the crypto index fund, organizing the assets and selling "shares" that give you a stake in the combined performance of the cryptocurrencies it contains. For investors who prefer a more blockchain-native approach, decentralized crypto index funds use blockchain technology to oversee the funds without a central authority.

Whether centralized or decentralized, all crypto index funds aim to simplify market access by providing exposure to a group of digital assets. Some funds focus on reflecting the broader crypto market, while others target niches like non-fungible tokens (NFTs), decentralized finance (DeFi), or GameFi. Investors benefit from the weighted average price performance of these assets without the complexities of managing wallets or constantly rebalancing portfolios.

Types of crypto index funds 

A variety of crypto index funds exist, each with different management techniques and focus areas within the crypto market. Choosing the right crypto index fund depends on a trader’s risk appetite and what areas of the market they're most interested in exploring. 

Crypto ETFs

Exchange-traded funds (ETFs) are one of the most accessible ways for investors to gain exposure to cryptocurrency price movements. They trade on traditional financial exchanges like the New York Stock Exchange (NYSE), similar to company shares, allowing investors to indirectly participate in the performance of underlying digital assets without directly owning them.

Crypto ETFs are generally categorized into two main types: futures-based ETFs, which track derivatives tied to cryptocurrency prices, and spot crypto ETFs, which directly hold cryptocurrencies like Bitcoin. While spot Bitcoin ETFs are highly sought after for their liquidity, newer ETFs are diversifying to include altcoins like Ethereum (ETH) and niche sectors such as crypto mining operations or NFTs.

Hedge funds 

Crypto hedge funds are often popular among seasoned accredited investors because they offer access to advanced trading strategies and tools typically unavailable to the average retail trader. Techniques like arbitrage, algorithmic trading, and high-frequency trading (HFT) allow hedge funds to capitalize on market inefficiencies, even in highly volatile conditions. For approved investors, these funds provide a way to diversify portfolios and potentially achieve higher-than-average returns by leveraging professional expertise and cutting-edge trading methods. However, the appeal often comes with a willingness to accept higher risk, and they aren’t available to the general public.

Comprehensive market index

Although still in its early stages, the crypto market now features indexes designed to track its broader ecosystem. A standout example is the Coinbase 50 Index (COIN50), introduced in 2024 by the centralized exchange (CEX) Coinbase. Modeled after the S&P 500, COIN50 includes 50 of the largest cryptocurrencies, weighted by market value and rebalanced quarterly. Coinbase has also expanded its offerings with COIN50 perpetuals, giving investors a new way to speculate on the crypto market’s overall performance.

Tokenized index funds

Cryptocurrency tokens are digital assets created on blockchains using automated programs called "smart contracts." These code-based systems handle a token's issuance and transfers, eliminating the need for third-party intermediaries. In crypto index funds, tokenization enables the creation of tamper-proof digital currencies that mirror the price movements of traditionally managed index funds.

Some tokenized index funds align with crypto's emphasis on community ownership by using decentralized autonomous organizations (DAOs). DAOs collectively manage decisions about the fund's assets, removing reliance on centralized third parties. For example, the DeFi Pulse Index (DPI) represents the combined value of a pool of DeFi tokens in a tokenized format.

There’s also growing interest in tokenizing traditional index funds, such as those based on the S&P 500. In theory, this could allow investors to access established assets through crypto wallets, bypassing intermediaries like brokerage firms. However, this concept is still highly experimental and not yet widely available due to regulatory uncertainties, particularly regarding securities laws and the lack of established infrastructure.

While tokenized index funds for traditional assets are still emerging (at the time of writing), crypto-native options like DPI are already available, providing a glimpse into the potential of blockchain-powered financial products. As regulations evolve, these innovative funds may become a more prominent feature of both traditional and decentralized finance.

Benefits and downsides of crypto index funds

Crypto index funds make investing in the crypto market easier, but that simplicity comes with a few trade-offs. One big downside is having to rely on outside entities – like CEXs, custodians, or DAOs – to manage and protect your funds.

Here’s a closer look at the pros and cons of crypto index funds:

Pros of crypto index funds

• Accessible and simple to understand: Crypto index funds aim to make digital asset investing more approachable, even for those without extensive Web3 knowledge or experience with crypto wallets. These funds offer straightforward ways to participate in the blockchain space without needing advanced technical expertise. 
• Diversification: While some ETFs focus on a single cryptocurrency, many crypto index funds provide exposure to multiple digital assets. These multi-coin funds spread risk across various crypto projects, helping to mitigate the volatility of any one token.  
• Automated portfolio rebalancing: Investors don’t need to constantly monitor the market or adjust their portfolios. Index fund managers handle rebalancing at set intervals or during significant market shifts, ensuring portfolios stay aligned with the fund’s strategy.
• Time and cost efficiency: Although management fees apply, they’re often lower than the costs of manually managing individual crypto positions. Investors also save time and effort by gaining exposure to a broad range of assets through a single fund. 

Cons of crypto index funds 

• Third-party reliance: Even if investors use a decentralized crypto index fund, they must rely on an external entity to safeguard their digital assets, whether a CEX, custodian, or DAO. This lack of direct control can be a concern for investors who prioritize self-custody.
• Management fees: Investors need to factor in the extra costs for management associated with a crypto index fund position. Even if the fund performs well, these costs cut into potential gains.
• Lack of customization: Investors don’t have direct input on portfolio adjustments. Decisions about asset selection and rebalancing are left to the fund manager, which may not align with every trader’s preferences.
• Potentially lower returns: By mirroring the market, crypto index funds are unlikely to outperform it. While diversification helps reduce volatility, it also means missing out on the higher returns of standout assets that exceed market averages.

How to invest in a crypto index fund: Basic strategies to choose a crypto index fund

As more crypto index funds enter the market, investors have more opportunities to diversify their portfolios and explore different areas of the digital economy. For those looking to invest in crypto while minimizing the complexity of managing individual assets, crypto index funds offer a streamlined solution. To find the fund that best fits your strategy or goals, here are four key features to consider:

• Methodology and fund composition: First, look into the strategy behind how a crypto index fund selects and weights the assets in its portfolio. For example, do all the digital assets in this fund have equal weight, or do cryptocurrencies with a higher market capitalization hold higher percentages? Alternatively, does an investment firm use a thematic approach to investing? If so, what areas of Web3 receive the most attention? 
• Assets under management (AUM): A crypto index fund's AUM shows the current pool of capital investors deposited into the account. Typically, higher AUMs imply a greater sense of investor confidence, as well as improved liquidity and stability.
• Historical returns: Past performance never guarantees future returns, but it's a valuable metric to consider when choosing between crypto index funds. Analyze how long different index funds have been around and how they performed over their timeframe to understand each manager's competency. 

Is there a crypto index fund in your portfolio? Track digital funds with CoinTracker 

No matter how you invest in crypto, whether you’re investing into crypto index funds or individual tokens, CoinTracker’s Portfolio Tracker connects seamlessly to 500+ exchanges and wallets, giving you a real-time view of your Web3 net worth. Calculate gains, spot tax-loss harvesting opportunities, and generate IRS-compliant forms ready for TurboTax, H&R Block, or your CPA – all in one place, all in minutes.

Get started with a free account today and join the millions of crypto investors already using CoinTracker to simplify their crypto tax reporting.

Disclaimer: This post is informational only and is not intended as tax advice. For tax advice, please consult a tax professional.